InSUBordination Blog Logo: The insubordinate dog

InSUBordination - Wag the dog

Sometimes you might have the feeling that your boss, your government or anybody else is just wrong. To make sure you are right you reflect the pros and cons of a problem. After careful consideration you might have the right or even duty to disobey his decisions. This behaviour would be in accordance with Immanuel Kants demand of "leaving a man's self-caused immaturity." Btw.: Don't take this stuff too serious. It's what I write when I'm pissed.

Tuesday, March 28, 2006

Incompetent bosses - unskilled and not aware of it.

Incompetent bosses suffer a dual burden. Not only do these bosses reach erroneous conclusions and make unfortunate choices, but their incompetence robs them of the metacognitive ability to realize it. As a result incompetent bosses tend to hold overly favorable views of their abilities in many social and intellectual domains despite logic and statistical evaluation of their skills defies their views.

This seems to be quit a catch21 and unfotunately we are all prone to a similar imperfect apraisal of ourself as illustrated by the fact of the average person to believe he or she is above average, a result that defies the logic of descriptive statistics. Yet, an incompetent Boss is exceptionally difficult. Tough you don't need to obey to unreasonable order you still have troubles dealing with an incompetent boss for serveral reasons :
  1. an incompetent boss can't possibly realize by himself that his order was unreasonable or unfortunate.
  2. they won't accept any advice from their subordinates because of their bold self-esteem
  3. Since he is the boss there is no supervisor who will correct his erraneous decisions
Problem #3 gets even more difficult since bosses usually have strong networking skills and high social position. Considering that abilities of socially high standing persons are evaluated less critically as their competence is considered to be immanent to their position, this means that refusal to obey to an unreasonable order of an incompetent boss will most likely be interpreted as insubordination, no matter what you do. Yet, if you comply to an unreasonable order this will problably have adverse side effects. The incompetent boss will not understand that these adverse effects are the result of his unreasonable order since his lacks the ability to realize this fact. As a result you will be accused for doing a bad job. As a result you are in a loose loose situation when dealing with an incompetent boss.

To deal with a bad boss I can think only of two possible strategies.

  1. You can try to make the boss more competent. Provide him with additional training and information. You have to do this very carefully so he isen't aware of what you are doing. Due to their overly favoerable view of their own person they won't accept advice from other individuals. If you get trough to them the boss might get insight in his shortcoming. Of course you will not be acknowledged for this because the boss will hold the strong belief that he accomplished to identify his error on his own and he just saved you from doing a terrible mistake.
  2. If strategy 1 doesen't work your best bet will be to find and other job a.s.a.p. or the incompetent boss will ruin your career. To continue working for him would be deleterions to you.
Since most likely all competent employees of an incompetent boss will eventally choose to quit this will leave the boss alone with incompetent subordinates. These incompetent subordinates will, like their boss, lack the ability to realize how unreasoble the decisions of an incompetent boss are. As a result they won't complain working for an incompetent boss. Vice versa the incompetent boss can't be aware of the incompetence of his subordinates since he lacks the cognitive ability. In the end an incompetent leader can cause considerable damage to a department, corporation or even country.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home

Search


this blog all blogs

Previous Posts

Definition of insubordination

Criminally braindead bosses

To all those bastard low-life bosses out there lur...

Don'ts when plan to refuse to comply to an order

Refusal to obey orders is not always insubordination

The matrix has you! What is the Matrix?

How to find out you got a boss from hell?

Fire your boss!

How to kick the ass of you boss

New message board script needed.Tag-board.com scri...

Alan Moore Quote

Quotes

The greatest achievement is to surpass yourself

The Future Belongs to Those Which Believe in Visions

There is Nothing in Existence Which Can not be Changed

He Who Stops to Improve has Ceased to Exist

Selfconfidence is the Key to Success

He Who Climbs the Highest Mountain has to Face the Strongest Winds

The only thing we have to fear is fear itself

How deep down does the rabbit hole go?

When law and morality contradict each other, the citizen has the cruel alternative of either losing his moral sense or losing his respect for the law

When the emperor has no clothes, you have to have the presence of mind and the courage to stand up and say,'The emperor has no clothes

To be a good memeber of a flock of sheeps you need to be a sheep yourself but then, if your shepherd is a sheep too, you are doomed!

Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional Powered by Blogger Creative Commons License inSUBordination